With our pellet fireplace insert ratings, you can compare pellet fireplace insert models side by side using our Head To Head tool.
You can compare 17 different models from 12 brands in nine categories such as warranty, heating capacity, cost, availability, & where they are made.
You can also read the individual reviews of each brand below.
Our simple rating system gives each brand a color code and a star rating. If the card is green, then, that is one of the top picks from HvacRepairGuy. If the card is yellow, then, that would be a budget pick from HvacRepairgGuy. If the card is red, then, the brand is not recommended by HvacRepairGuy. With our pellet fireplace insert reviews, you can cut through the sales hype and find value. It truly is like you were taking a repairman shopping with you!
This brand is from US Stove Company and the inserts can be purchased at many hardware and home improvement stores such as The Home Depot, Lowes, and Menards. The 6041i model is backed by a very good guarantee and can burn multiple types of fuel such as grains as well as wood pellets. The inserts feature automatic ignition with digital controls and a five speed fan to distribute the heat throughout the home as well as an air wash system to keep the glass clean for viewing the fire. They have a burn pot agitator that provides a more complete burn and eliminates clinker buildup and requires less maintenance. The units have a 52,300 BTU heating capacity with a 60 pound hopper for the pellets. The 5040i model is slightly smaller with a 45 pound hopper and it only burns wood pellets.
This brand is from National Steelcrafters and is available through a limited dealer network in North America. The BLAZER model features digital controls with an automatic fire starter as well as a stainless steel burn pot for durability. The insert has a built-in heat exchanger tube cleaner that helps to keep the unit working at rated efficiency and an air wash system to keep the glass clean for viewing the fire. The units have a 70 pound pellet hopper with a 50,000 BTU heating capacity and do not require an external thermostat but, if one is installed, it must be a millivolt thermostat. The warranty on the heat exchanger is not as good as many brands.
This brand is from SMG Hearth & Home and can be purchased at The Home depot as well as through their website and on Amazon. The HP22I model has a bay window for viewing the fire as well as automatic ignition and a programmable internal thermostat. They have a 50,000 BTU heating capacity and five power settings as well as a standard blower to distribute the heat throughout the room but the guarantee on the units is not very good when compared to other brands.
This brand is from Sierra Products and features a 12 volt control system. The 4001B1-N inserts can be connected to a battery to operate during power outages. They have digital controls and an autolite system for starting the fire based on thermostat demand. The units are made in the USA but they are only sold through a limited dealer network and the warranty on the units (especially the heat exchanger) is not very good when compared to other brands.
This brand is made in Canada by Sherwood Industries Limited and they are backed by a good guarantee but their products are only sold through authorized dealers. The EF2 features "tri-mode" operation where the unit can be controlled manually, automatically through a thermostat, or with two stages (hi/lo) through a thermostat. The unit has a variable speed fan as well as an air wash system for keeping the glass clean for viewing the fire. The M55 model features cast iron construction for that traditional look and feel while the Meridian model is a large unit with more modern styling.
This brand is from Hearth & Home Technologies and the inserts are only sold through authorized dealers but they are backed by a good warranty. The units feature easy touch controls with a wireless room sensor to accurately maintain the room temperature as well as an air wash system to keep the glass clean for viewing the fire. The P42i-TC model has a large 64 pound pellet hopper with a 41,800 BTU heating capacity while the Accentra 52i-TC model has a 51,800 BTU heating capacity and flame reactive mirrored glass for viewing the fire.
This brand is made in the USA and is backed by a good warranty but the stoves are only available through a limited dealer network. The Davenport inserts feature digital automatic controls, an electronic igniter, and they are thermostat ready. They have a quiet variable speed fan to distribute the heat and a durable stainless steel burn pot. The units have a 60 pound pellet hopper and a 49,000 BTU heating capacity.
This brand is made in the USA by Innovative Hearth Products and the inserts are backed by a very good guarantee but they are only available through a very limited dealer network in the USA and Canada. The Winslow model features bay windows for viewing the fire and an airwash system to keep the glass clean. They feature automatic operation, a 55 pound pellet hopper, and a 37,500 BTU heating capacity but they are rather expensive compared to some of the other brands. The units have a self-cleaning burnpot which minimizes maintenance and maintains rated efficiency.
This brand is made in the USA by Travis Industries and is available through dealers in North America and Australia. The AGP insert can burn all grades of pellets and is certified for clean burning by the EPA. They have a large 70 pound pellet hopper and a durable stainless steel burn platform as well as an air wash system to keep the glass clean for viewing the fire. They have a variable speed fan to distribute the heat throughout the room and they are backed by a decent guarantee.
This brand is from Hearth & Home Technologies and the fireplace inserts are backed by a very good guarantee but they are only sold through a very limited dealer network. The Trekker Series offers EPA certified clean burning units with a 51,000 BTU heating capacity and a 52 pound pellet hopper as well as a seven day programmable thermostat. The units feature durable cast iron heat exchangers and firepots and an optional temperature sensing remote control. The insert automatically adjusts the burn rate and variable speed fan to maximize efficiency and maintain the proper temperature.
These units are from Fireplace Products International and they are sold through dealers in the USA and Canada but it is a very limited network and their guarantee is only average when compared to other brands. The Greenfire GFI55 features a large bay window for wonderful views of the fire and an air wash system to keep the glass clean. The unit has a relatively large hopper (55 pound) and a variable speed blower for enhanced comfort. The Hampton GCI60 model has a more tradition look and feel to it with cast iron construction and it has the ability to burn various grains as well as wood pellets.
This brand can be purchased at many hardware and home improvement stores such as Tractor Supply. The 6041i model is backed by a very good guarantee and can burn multiple types of fuel such as grains as well as wood pellets. The inserts feature automatic ignition with digital controls and a five speed fan to distribute the heat throughout the home as well as an air wash system to keep the glass clean for viewing the fire. They have a burn pot agitator that provides a more complete burn and eliminates clinker buildup and requires less maintenance. The units have a 52,300 BTU heating capacity with a 60 pound hopper for the pellets.
| Select Insert | ||
|---|---|---|
| Brand | N/A | N/A |
| Model | N/A | N/A |
| Automatic Ignition | N/A | N/A |
| Hopper Capacity | N/A | N/A |
| Heat Output | N/A | N/A |
| Blower Type | N/A | N/A |
| Parts Warranty | N/A | N/A |
| Heat Exchanger Warranty | N/A | N/A |
| Dealer Required | N/A | N/A |
| Factory Location | N/A | N/A |
| Cost | N/A | N/A |